115-year-old Supreme Court Case could determine if states can force you to wear a mask

Legal Resources 0 Comments 09/24/2020  

Wearing a mask has become the new normal amid the coronavirus pandemic, but whether or not the government can force you to wear one has become a topic of contention.

The argument pits the power of government to protect the public’s health against the Constitution’s protection of civil liberties. As people consider challenging mask mandates in the courts, there’s a Supreme Court decision against a Massachusetts man who refused vaccination during a smallpox outbreak that keeps coming up as a reference point for legal battles.

Jacobson v. Massachusetts could be used in the argument when trying to justify the government’s abilities to curb one’s liberties in the interest of public health as it expands on the state’s capacity to regulate behavior and enforce order within their territory for the betterment of the health, safety, morals and general welfare of residents. This is otherwise known in constitutional law as a state’s police power.

In 1902, the city asked the board of health in Cambridge, Massachusetts for advice to mitigate the smallpox outbreak. The board adopted a regulation that those who had not been vaccinated should be, the board asking the city to make vaccinations a requirement.

Read the regulation below:

“Whereas, smallpox has been prevalent to some extent in the city of Cambridge, and still continues to increase; and whereas, it is necessary for the speedy extermination of the disease that all persons not protected by vaccination should be vaccinated; and whereas, in the opinion of the board, the public health and safety require the vaccination or revaccination of all the inhabitants of Cambridge; be it ordered, that all the inhabitants habitants of the city who have not been successfully vaccinated since March 1st, 1897, be vaccinated or revaccinated.”

A criminal complaint was then filed against Jacobson in the state’s lower courts. According to court records, the 21-year-old refused to comply with the requirement.

Jacobson argued the vaccine mandate infringed upon his federal rights as outlined in the preamble of the U.S. Constitution also pointing to the clauses that no state shall make or enforce any law abridging the privileges or immunities of citizens of the U.S. He was arguing the state was overstepping its police power.

As the case moved through the courts, Jacobson’s defense was that the smallpox vaccination “quite often” caused serious and permanent injury to the health of the person vaccinated and occasionally in death.

The court ruled that epidemic played a huge factor in the decision, saying the widespread smallpox outbreak justified a general rule for vaccination, saying the state was working to protect public health and safety.

“Such an answer would mean that compulsory vaccination could not, in any conceivable case, be legally enforced in a community, even at the command of the legislature, however widespread the epidemic of smallpox, and however deep and universal was the belief of the community and of its medical advisers that a system of general vaccination was vital to the safety of all.”

The case sets a precedent as it is interpreted that all constitutional rights may be reasonably restricted when fighting a public health emergency. The Supreme Court upheld the authority of states to enforce compulsory vaccination laws.

Though the court came to the conclusion that the legislation did not invade any right secured by the Federal Constitution, the justices outlined that their decision should not be interpreted for abuse of power.

“To suppose the case of an adult who is embraced by the mere words of the act, but yet to subject whom to vaccination in a particular condition of his health or body would be cruel and inhuman in the last degree. We are not to be understood as holding that the statute was intended to be applied to such a case, or, if it was so intended, that the judiciary would not be competent to interfere and protect the health and life of the individual concerned. ‘All laws,’ this court has said, ‘should receive a sensible construction. General terms should be so limited in their application as not to lead to injustice, oppression, or an absurd consequence,” the court clarified.

The justices further outlined their decision does not mean the absolute rule that an adult must be vaccinated saying there are other considerations such as if a person is not fit for vaccination, or if the vaccination could impair their health or cause probable cause of death, items that the defendant in the case could not personally prove.

“We now decide that the statute covers the present case,” the decision reads. Court documents read the minority cannot control what’s done for the health and safety of the majority furthering the point a state is allowed to do things its public does not approve of if it’s an informed decision that is in the interest of the health, safety, morals and general welfare of their inhabitants. The country’s balance of powers is meant to make sure states are not abusing this power or misusing it in which the justices found Massachusetts was not.

Again, the context is in the timeline. It’s been more than 100 years since the case and public health and personal liberty laws have changed and a state’s police power has been further outlined.

There’s now the right to refuse treatment, the necessity for a present and imminent threat of disease, and more modern constitutional law. Ultimately, it would largely depend on the case challenging mask mandates and the regulation itself for a court to come to a decision.

   When his home closed to visitors for the second time, it had a devastating effect on my father’s mental health, so I decided to take actionBy Jacqui Deevoy“This is the most fun I’ve had in a long time.” These were my dear dad’s words on his first night back in his own house after spending the year in a private care home. He looked so comfortable in familiar surroundin...  READ MORE
- Fielden Nolan (nolanf),  10/21/2020 
   curated by Marilyn M. Singleton, M.D., J.D. – September 26, 2020IntroductionCOVID-19 is as politically-charged as it is infectious. Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, the WHO, the CDC and NIH’s Dr. Anthony Fauci discouraged wearing masks as not useful for non-health care workers. Now they recommend wearing cloth face coverings in public setting...  READ MORE
- Fielden Nolan (nolanf),  10/18/2020 
   - October 17, 2020STORY AT-A-GLANCEThe German Corona Extra-Parliamentary Inquiry Committee (Außerparlamentarischer Corona Untersuchungsausschuss), launched July 10, 2020, was founded by four trial attorneys to investigate and prosecute those responsible for implementing the economically devastating lockdowns around the world, as well as using fraudulent testing to engineer the appearance of ...  READ MORE
- Fielden Nolan (nolanf),  10/17/2020 
   October 14, 2020:Publisher Note: Given the public interest in articles which report on vaccination, the publisher reminds readers that correlation (which this article reports upon for a specific age group) does not necessarily equal causation. As such, this article should not be taken to suggest that receiving the influenza vaccination results in an increased risk of death for an in...  READ MORE
- Fielden Nolan (nolanf),  10/14/2020 
   - October 13, 2020One of the hallmarks of totalitarianism is mass conformity to a psychotic official narrative. Not a regular official narrative, like the “Cold War” or the “War on Terror” narratives. A totally delusional official narrative that has little or no connection to reality and that is contradicted by a preponderance of facts.Nazism and Stalinism are the classic e...  READ MORE
- Fielden Nolan (nolanf),  10/14/2020 
   - October 12, 2020Experts from UCL found 80pc of Covid patients did not have common symptomsMedics warn of a loss of taste or smell, a fever and dry cough are symptoms However, research now shows many survivors suffer long term side effects The virus can damage many organs which affect the ongoing quality of life Swollen toes, prickly skin, long-term heart damage, disturbing halluci...  READ MORE
- Fielden Nolan (nolanf),  10/12/2020 
   Highlights• Hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) 2400 mg over 5 days was used in Belgium for COVID-19.• Impact of HCQ on mortality among 8075 patients with COVID-19 was assessed.• Lower mortality in HCQ-treated patients as compared to supportive care.• Lower mortality was irrespective of symptom duration.ABSTRACTHydroxychloroquine (HCQ) has been largely used and investigated as therapy for...  READ MORE
- Fielden Nolan (nolanf),  10/05/2020 
   - October 1, 2020Originally published on the Oral Health website, it vanished in June 2020 and was replaced with the statement, “…it has been removed. The content was published in 2016 and is no longer relevant in our current climate.” Who would have the clout, time and money to scour the Internet to force removal of anti-face mask research papers? This is “book burni...  READ MORE
- Fielden Nolan (nolanf),  10/02/2020 
   - September 28, 2020In the Soviet Union it was forbidden to dispute the wisdom of the “party line.” That’s because Marxian communism was viewed as the scientifically inevitable progression of mankind. For Marx and Lenin, the “science was settled.” Therefore anyone speaking out against “the science” of the Soviet system must be acting with malice; must...  READ MORE
- Fielden Nolan (nolanf),  09/29/2020 
   “The great masses of men, though theoretically free, are seen to submit supinely to oppression and exploitation of a hundred abhorrent sorts. Have they no means of resistance? Obviously they have. The worst tyrant, even under democratic plutocracy, has but one throat to slit. The moment the majority decided to overthrow him he would be overthrown. But the majority lacks the resolution; it ca...  READ MORE
- Fielden Nolan (nolanf),  09/28/2020 

VIEW News Item

FL: Anthony Sabatini files 8 lawsuits over mandatory mask mandates

"It’s overkill, and it’s not the role of government."
VIEW News Item

UK: Thousands of COVID-19 deaths 'will be wiped off the official toll'

Counted victims if they died from any cause months later after beating disease
VIEW News Item

Model Bella Hadid gives the NYPD the middle finger

Calls out police officers for not wearing masks
VIEW News Item

GA: Police departments report zero citations for face mask violations

"the requirements to wear a largely symbolic"
VIEW News Item

Dozens gather to protest Maine’s mask mandate

“I’m going to do whatever it takes and so are all of us to force this issue..."

VIEW Blog Item

A Message to Maskers

Do you believe nomaskers are a threat? If so, read on...

We appreciate your donations to NOMASKERS.ORG, because without them this site would not be possible. You do not need a PayPal account in order to donate with your credit card. Just click on the Donate button below. You will be prompted for the amount you wish to contribute.